This is Set 14 of 42 in the smartvidya question bank on the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964. Part III: Media, criticism, evidence and information. This set covers Rule 9(i)–(iii), the media covered, the association office-bearers proviso and the official-capacity exception.
Try each question first, then tap Show answer to see the correct option, a short explanation and the rule reference. The gift limits in Rule 13(3) are as revised in 2019, and share-trading intimation follows the DoPT OM of 07.02.2019.
Set 14: Rule 9 – Criticism of Government
1. Rule 9 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules deals with:
(a) Evidence before committees
(b) Connection with press
(c) Criticism of Government
(d) Subscriptions
Ans. (c) Criticism of Government — Explanation: Rule 9 bars statements of fact or opinion that adversely criticise Government policy or embarrass relations with States or foreign countries. [Ref: Rule 9]
2. Rule 9(i) bars statements which have the effect of an adverse criticism of which policies or actions?
(a) Only policies older than five years
(b) Any current or recent policy or action of the Central Government or a State Government
(c) Only policies of the Central Government
(d) Only policies of foreign Governments
Ans. (b) Any current or recent policy or action of the Central Government or a State Government — Explanation: Rule 9(i) covers any current or recent policy or action of the Central Government or a State Government. [Ref: Rule 9(i)]
3. Which of the following is NOT one of the channels expressly covered by Rule 9?
(a) A private conversation with his spouse at home
(b) A communication to the press
(c) A radio broadcast or telecast through any electronic media
(d) A document published anonymously or pseudonymously
Ans. (a) A private conversation with his spouse at home — Explanation: Rule 9 covers broadcasts, telecasts, documents published in his own or another's name or anonymously or pseudonymously, communications to the press and public utterances. Private conversation at home is not covered. [Ref: Rule 9]
4. A Government servant writes under a pen name in a magazine criticising a recent Central Government policy. Is he in breach of Rule 9?
(a) Yes, Rule 9 covers documents published anonymously, pseudonymously or in the name of another person
(b) Only if he is paid for it
(c) No, since it was a magazine, not a newspaper
(d) No, since he used a pen name
Ans. (a) Yes, Rule 9 covers documents published anonymously, pseudonymously or in the name of another person — Explanation: Rule 9 expressly covers documents published in his own name or anonymously, pseudonymously or in the name of any other person. [Ref: Rule 9]
5. Rule 9(ii) bars statements capable of embarrassing the relations between:
(a) Two private companies
(b) Two political parties
(c) The Central Government and the Government of any State
(d) The Government servant and his superior
Ans. (c) The Central Government and the Government of any State — Explanation: Rule 9(ii) is about relations between the Central Government and any State Government. [Ref: Rule 9(ii)]
6. Rule 9(iii) bars statements capable of embarrassing the relations between the Central Government and:
(a) The judiciary
(b) The Government of any foreign State
(c) Public sector undertakings
(d) Service associations
Ans. (b) The Government of any foreign State — Explanation: Rule 9(iii) covers statements capable of embarrassing the relations between the Central Government and the Government of any foreign State. [Ref: Rule 9(iii)]
7. Under the proviso at the end of Rule 9, which statements are outside its scope?
(a) Statements made after office hours
(b) Statements made or views expressed in his official capacity or in the due performance of duties assigned to him
(c) Statements made to foreign journalists
(d) Statements made on social media
Ans. (b) Statements made or views expressed in his official capacity or in the due performance of duties assigned to him — Explanation: Nothing in Rule 9 applies to statements made or views expressed by a Government servant in his official capacity or in the due performance of his duties. [Ref: Rule 9, proviso]
8. A Government servant in the Ministry of External Affairs, as official spokesperson, criticises a foreign Government's action at a press briefing. Is this a breach of Rule 9(iii)?
(a) Yes, unless he obtained previous sanction
(b) Only if the foreign Government complains
(c) Yes, since it may embarrass relations
(d) No, statements made in official capacity are excluded
Ans. (d) No, statements made in official capacity are excluded — Explanation: The proviso excludes statements made in official capacity or in due performance of assigned duties. [Ref: Rule 9, proviso]
9. Which category of Government servants gets a special proviso under Rule 9(i) for bona fide expression of views as office-bearers of trade unions or associations?
(a) All Group 'A' officers
(b) All members of recognised associations
(c) All Government servants on deputation
(d) Those covered by the second proviso to Rule 1(3), that is low-paid non-gazetted staff in specified industrial establishments
Ans. (d) Those covered by the second proviso to Rule 1(3), that is low-paid non-gazetted staff in specified industrial establishments — Explanation: The proviso to Rule 9(i) protects bona fide expression of views, by such employees as office-bearers of a trade union or association, for safeguarding or improving their conditions of service. [Ref: Rule 9(i), proviso]
10. The proviso to Rule 9(i) protects expression of views by such office-bearers only for which purpose?
(a) Criticising judges
(b) Safeguarding the conditions of service of such employees or securing improvement in them
(c) Criticising foreign policy
(d) Supporting a political party
Ans. (b) Safeguarding the conditions of service of such employees or securing improvement in them — Explanation: The protection is limited to bona fide expression of views for safeguarding or improving the conditions of service of the employees concerned. [Ref: Rule 9(i), proviso]
11. A Government servant makes a public speech saying a Central scheme launched last month is "a total failure designed to fool people". Which rule is breached?
(a) Rule 8(1)
(b) Rule 11
(c) Rule 10(2)
(d) Rule 9(i)
Ans. (d) Rule 9(i) — Explanation: A public utterance adversely criticising a current or recent policy of the Central Government breaches Rule 9(i). [Ref: Rule 9(i)]
12. Rule 9 bars a statement of:
(a) Fact only
(b) Personal belief only in writing
(c) Opinion only
(d) Fact or opinion
Ans. (d) Fact or opinion — Explanation: The rule says "make any statement of fact or opinion", so even factual statements that have the effect of adverse criticism are covered. [Ref: Rule 9]
13. A Government servant posts on social media a message capable of embarrassing relations between the Centre and a State over a water dispute. Which clause is breached?
(a) Rule 5(1)
(b) Rule 9(ii)
(c) Rule 7(i)
(d) Rule 9(iii)
Ans. (b) Rule 9(ii) — Explanation: Rule 9(ii) covers statements capable of embarrassing relations between the Central Government and the Government of any State. Posts on social media are public communications covered by the rule. [Ref: Rule 9(ii)]
14. Does Rule 9(i) protect criticism of a State Government's policy by a Central Government servant?
(a) Only if the State policy is more than a year old
(b) Yes, since he is a Central Government servant
(c) Yes, if the State is ruled by a different party
(d) No, Rule 9(i) covers policies of both the Central Government and State Governments
Ans. (d) No, Rule 9(i) covers policies of both the Central Government and State Governments — Explanation: Rule 9(i) bars adverse criticism of current or recent policy or action of the Central Government or a State Government. [Ref: Rule 9(i)]
15. Consider these statements about Rule 9: 1. It covers pseudonymous writing. 2. It covers statements made in official capacity. 3. It covers telecasts through electronic media. Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 3 only
(b) 1 and 2 only
(c) 1, 2 and 3
(d) 2 and 3 only
Ans. (a) 1 and 3 only — Explanation: Pseudonymous documents and telecasts are expressly covered. Statements in official capacity are excluded by the proviso. [Ref: Rule 9]
16. The words "current or recent" in Rule 9(i) mean:
(a) Criticism of policies of the distant past is not the focus of the rule
(b) Only policies announced in the last one month are covered
(c) Only policies under implementation by his own office
(d) Any policy ever adopted is covered
Ans. (a) Criticism of policies of the distant past is not the focus of the rule — Explanation: Rule 9(i) targets adverse criticism of current or recent policies or actions. Academic discussion of long-past policies is not what the rule aims at, though the other clauses still apply. [Ref: Rule 9(i)]
17. A Government servant, while giving evidence with sanction before a private enquiry, criticises a Government policy. Which rule deals specifically with this?
(a) Rule 10(2)
(b) Rule 11
(c) Rule 9(iii)
(d) Rule 8(3)
Ans. (a) Rule 10(2) — Explanation: Rule 10(2) says a Government servant giving evidence with sanction shall not criticise the policy or any action of the Central Government or a State Government. [Ref: Rule 10(2)]
18. Which statement about the scope of Rule 9 is correct?
(a) It applies only to statements in newspapers
(b) It applies only during elections
(c) It applies whether the statement is published in his own name, anonymously or in another's name
(d) It applies only to Group 'A' officers
Ans. (c) It applies whether the statement is published in his own name, anonymously or in another's name — Explanation: Rule 9 covers all these forms of publication, as well as broadcasts, telecasts, communications to the press and public utterances. [Ref: Rule 9]
19. A Government servant gives a talk to students on constitutional history without criticising any current policy. Is Rule 9 breached?
(a) No, Rule 9 bars adverse criticism of current or recent policy and embarrassing statements, not general education
(b) Only if the talk is recorded
(c) Yes, unless he takes previous sanction under Rule 9
(d) Yes, all public talks are barred
Ans. (a) No, Rule 9 bars adverse criticism of current or recent policy and embarrassing statements, not general education — Explanation: Rule 9 targets specific kinds of statements. A talk that does not adversely criticise current or recent policy or embarrass relations is outside it. [Ref: Rule 9]
20. Rule 9 bars adverse criticism in which of the following?
(a) A confidential note to his superior on file
(b) A draft prepared for his Minister
(c) A public utterance
(d) An official report submitted in due course of duty
Ans. (c) A public utterance — Explanation: A public utterance is expressly covered. Notes on file, drafts and official reports are made in official capacity and are excluded by the proviso. [Ref: Rule 9]
21. A Government servant emails a newspaper a letter criticising the Central Government's recent tax policy for publication. Which statement is correct?
(a) It is barred only if the letter is published
(b) It is permitted because letters to editors are private
(c) It is a communication to the press having the effect of adverse criticism, barred by Rule 9(i)
(d) It is permitted if he signs his name
Ans. (c) It is a communication to the press having the effect of adverse criticism, barred by Rule 9(i) — Explanation: Rule 9 covers any communication to the press. The breach lies in making the statement through that channel. [Ref: Rule 9(i)]
22. Which of the following is correct about Rule 9 and Rule 8?
(a) Both deal only with ownership of newspapers
(b) Rule 8 bars all criticism of Government
(c) Rule 9 requires previous sanction to publish articles
(d) Rule 8 governs owning and editing media; Rule 9 governs the content of statements
Ans. (d) Rule 8 governs owning and editing media; Rule 9 governs the content of statements — Explanation: Rule 8 is about connection with press and media (ownership, editing, management). Rule 9 is about the content of statements, in whatever medium. [Ref: Rules 8, 9]
23. Under Rule 9, which clause deals with embarrassing relations with a foreign State?
(a) Clause (iii)
(b) Clause (i)
(c) The proviso
(d) Clause (ii)
Ans. (a) Clause (iii) — Explanation: Rule 9(i) is adverse criticism of policy, Rule 9(ii) relations with States, and Rule 9(iii) relations with foreign States. [Ref: Rule 9(iii)]
24. A Government servant who is a union office-bearer in a Central power establishment (drawing pay below Rs. 500 per mensem) publicly criticises a Government order cutting their overtime allowance. Which statement is correct?
(a) He is protected only if he takes previous sanction
(b) He is protected even if he criticises foreign policy
(c) The proviso to Rule 9(i) may protect bona fide views expressed to safeguard their conditions of service
(d) He is always in breach of Rule 9(i)
Ans. (c) The proviso to Rule 9(i) may protect bona fide views expressed to safeguard their conditions of service — Explanation: The proviso protects bona fide expression of views, by such office-bearers, to safeguard or improve their conditions of service. It does not extend to embarrassing relations with States or foreign countries. [Ref: Rule 9(i), proviso]
25. Which of these is expressly mentioned in Rule 9 as a medium for prohibited statements?
(a) Office noting
(b) Telecast through any electronic media
(c) Letter to a family member
(d) Personal diary
Ans. (b) Telecast through any electronic media — Explanation: Rule 9 mentions radio broadcasts, telecasts through any electronic media, published documents, communications to the press and public utterances. [Ref: Rule 9]
Want all 1,050 questions in one PDF? The CCS (Conduct) Rules ebook has every set with answers, explanations, rule references and quick-revision tables. Get the ebook
Next: Set 15. See all sets under the label CCS Conduct Rules. For exam preparation, attempt the full set before checking answers and note the rule number of every question you miss.
These questions are prepared for practice from the text of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and related Government of India instructions. Always check the latest DoPT orders before relying on any point for official decisions.