This is Set 4 of 40 in the smartvidya question bank on the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, with the latest amendments and DoPT instructions. Part I: General provisions and classification. This set covers Rules 8 and 9, Rule 2(a) meaning of appointing authority, Article 311(1).
Try each question first, then tap Show answer to see the correct option, a short explanation and the section or rule reference. The questions are useful for departmental and promotion examinations, for disciplinary authorities, inquiring and presenting officers, and vigilance staff.
Set 4: Part III: Appointing Authority
1. Who makes appointments to Central Civil Services, Group A and Central Civil Posts, Group A under Rule 8?
(a) The Cabinet Secretary
(b) The President
(c) The UPSC
(d) The head of the department
Ans. (b) The President — Explanation: Rule 8 provides that all appointments to Group A Services and posts shall be made by the President, subject to delegation under its proviso. [Ref: Rule 8]
2. Under the proviso to Rule 8, how may the President delegate the power to make Group A appointments?
(a) Only to the Secretary of the Ministry, without any conditions
(b) By a general or special order, to any other authority and subject to conditions specified in the order
(c) Only to the UPSC, by notification
(d) Only by an Act of Parliament
Ans. (b) By a general or special order, to any other authority and subject to conditions specified in the order — Explanation: The proviso allows the President, by a general or special order and subject to conditions he may specify, to empower another authority to make such appointments. [Ref: Rule 8, proviso]
3. Under Rule 9(1), who makes appointments to Central Civil Services (other than the General Central Service), Groups B and C?
(a) The President in every case
(b) The Staff Selection Commission
(c) The head of the office in every case
(d) The authorities specified in that behalf in the Schedule
Ans. (d) The authorities specified in that behalf in the Schedule — Explanation: Rule 9(1) requires such appointments to be made by the authorities specified in the Schedule for the Service concerned. [Ref: Rule 9(1)]
4. Who makes appointments to Group B and Group C posts included in the General Central Service?
(a) The Department of Personnel and Training in every case
(b) Any gazetted officer of the office concerned
(c) The UPSC in every case
(d) The authorities specified by a general or special order of the President, or failing such order, the authorities specified in the Schedule
Ans. (d) The authorities specified by a general or special order of the President, or failing such order, the authorities specified in the Schedule — Explanation: Rule 9(2) provides for appointment by authorities specified by Presidential order and, where no order exists, by the authorities specified in the Schedule. [Ref: Rule 9(2)]
5. Which rules make up Part III (Appointing Authority) of the CCS (CCA) Rules?
(a) Rules 4 to 7
(b) Rules 10 and 11
(c) Rules 8 and 9
(d) Rules 12 and 13
Ans. (c) Rules 8 and 9 — Explanation: Part III contains Rule 8 (Group A appointments) and Rule 9 (other appointments). [Ref: Part III]
6. What does Article 311(1) of the Constitution provide?
(a) No member of a civil service shall be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to that by which he was appointed
(b) No civil servant shall be transferred without his consent
(c) No suspension shall be ordered by an authority other than the President
(d) No penalty shall be imposed without consulting the UPSC
Ans. (a) No member of a civil service shall be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to that by which he was appointed — Explanation: Article 311(1) protects civil servants of the Union and States against dismissal or removal by an authority subordinate to their appointing authority. [Ref: Article 311(1)]
7. Against which actions does Article 311(1) expressly protect a civil servant?
(a) Censure and withholding of increments
(b) Suspension and transfer
(c) Recovery of pecuniary loss
(d) Dismissal and removal
Ans. (d) Dismissal and removal — Explanation: Article 311(1) speaks only of dismissal and removal; it does not regulate suspension, transfer or minor penalties. [Ref: Article 311(1)]
8. X was appointed in 2010 by the Chief Postmaster General. Later the power to appoint to that post was delegated to the Postmaster General. Who can dismiss X?
(a) The head of the office where X now works
(b) The Postmaster General, as the present appointing authority
(c) The Chief Postmaster General or a higher authority, but not the Postmaster General
(d) Any officer exercising disciplinary powers over X
Ans. (c) The Chief Postmaster General or a higher authority, but not the Postmaster General — Explanation: The authority which actually appointed X is an appointing authority under Rule 2(a) and the highest one counts; Article 311(1) bars dismissal by an authority subordinate to it. [Ref: Rule 2(a); Article 311(1)]
9. Under Rule 2(a), where a Government servant who was a permanent member of another Service has been in continuous Government employment, which authority is also counted as an appointing authority?
(a) The authority which appointed him to that other Service, grade or post
(b) The authority which approved his deputation
(c) The authority which last transferred him
(d) The authority which conducted his recruitment examination
Ans. (a) The authority which appointed him to that other Service, grade or post — Explanation: Rule 2(a)(iv) includes the authority which appointed him to that earlier Service, grade or post, and the highest of all such authorities is the appointing authority. [Ref: Rule 2(a)(iv)]
10. Which of the following is NOT relevant in identifying the appointing authority under Rule 2(a)?
(a) The authority empowered to appoint to the post he for the time being holds
(b) The authority empowered to appoint to the grade in which he is for the time being included
(c) The body that conducted the recruitment examination
(d) The authority which actually appointed him to the post
Ans. (c) The body that conducted the recruitment examination — Explanation: Rule 2(a) looks at the authorities empowered to appoint to the Service, grade or post and the authority which actually appointed him; a recruiting agency like UPSC or SSC only recommends. [Ref: Rule 2(a)]
11. Article 311(1) is NOT violated when a dismissal order is passed by which authority?
(a) The head of office who is subordinate to the appointing authority
(b) An authority immediately subordinate to the appointing authority
(c) An authority higher in rank than the appointing authority
(d) An authority two levels below the appointing authority
Ans. (c) An authority higher in rank than the appointing authority — Explanation: The bar is only against authorities subordinate to the appointing authority; a higher authority may impose dismissal or removal. [Ref: Article 311(1)]
12. X was appointed by a Director. Subsequently the power to make appointments to X's post was vested in a Joint Secretary. Who is X's appointing authority under Rule 2(a)?
(a) The Joint Secretary, being the highest of the authorities answering the description
(b) The head of the department in every case
(c) Either of them, at the choice of the disciplinary authority
(d) The Director, being the authority which actually appointed him
Ans. (a) The Joint Secretary, being the highest of the authorities answering the description — Explanation: Both answer the description in Rule 2(a), and the Rule makes the highest of them the appointing authority, here the Joint Secretary. [Ref: Rule 2(a)]
13. Does Article 311(1) require that a dismissal order be passed only by the very authority which appointed the Government servant?
(a) No; any authority may dismiss if the UPSC agrees
(b) Yes; unless the President specifically delegates the power
(c) No; any authority that is not subordinate to the appointing authority may pass it
(d) Yes; only the officer who signed the appointment order may dismiss
Ans. (c) No; any authority that is not subordinate to the appointing authority may pass it — Explanation: The Article only forbids dismissal or removal by a subordinate authority; the appointing authority or any higher authority may act. [Ref: Article 311(1)]
14. To whom is the protection of Article 311 available?
(a) Members of a civil service of the Union, an all-India service or a State civil service, and holders of civil posts
(b) Employees of statutory corporations and companies
(c) Members of the armed forces of the Union
(d) Only permanent gazetted officers of the Union
Ans. (a) Members of a civil service of the Union, an all-India service or a State civil service, and holders of civil posts — Explanation: Article 311 covers members of civil services and holders of civil posts under the Union or a State, whether permanent or temporary; armed forces and corporation employees are not covered. [Ref: Article 311]
15. Is the UPSC the appointing authority for Group A posts filled on its recommendation?
(a) Yes, but only for posts filled by direct recruitment
(b) No; the UPSC only recommends, and the appointment is made by the President or the delegated authority
(c) No; the Department of Personnel always makes such appointments
(d) Yes; the UPSC issues the appointment orders
Ans. (b) No; the UPSC only recommends, and the appointment is made by the President or the delegated authority — Explanation: Under Rule 8 the President (or delegate) appoints; the UPSC's role under Article 320 is advisory and recommendatory. [Ref: Rule 8; Article 320]
16. Why is correct identification of the appointing authority important in disciplinary cases?
(a) Because dismissal or removal by an authority subordinate to it is barred by Article 311(1)
(b) Because only the appointing authority may impose censure
(c) Because only the appointing authority may conduct the oral inquiry
(d) Because only the appointing authority may issue a charge-sheet
Ans. (a) Because dismissal or removal by an authority subordinate to it is barred by Article 311(1) — Explanation: Charge-sheets, inquiries and minor penalties can be handled by other competent authorities, but dismissal or removal must not come from an authority below the appointing authority. [Ref: Article 311(1); Rule 2(a)]
17. A dismissal order is passed by an authority subordinate to the one that appointed the Government servant. What is the legal position of the order?
(a) It is valid if the UPSC was consulted
(b) It is valid if the charges are proved
(c) It violates Article 311(1) and is liable to be set aside
(d) It is valid if the Government servant did not object during the inquiry
Ans. (c) It violates Article 311(1) and is liable to be set aside — Explanation: The Article 311(1) protection is constitutional; proof of charges or consultation cannot cure an order passed by an incompetent subordinate authority. [Ref: Article 311(1)]
18. Under Rule 2(a)(i), the appointing authority includes the authority empowered to make appointments to which of the following?
(a) Any post in the Ministry, whether or not he holds it
(b) The Service of which the Government servant is for the time being a member, or the grade in which he is included
(c) Only the post he held on first appointment
(d) Only the post to which he is likely to be promoted
Ans. (b) The Service of which the Government servant is for the time being a member, or the grade in which he is included — Explanation: Rule 2(a)(i) refers to the authority empowered to appoint to the Service or the grade of the Service of which he is for the time being a member. [Ref: Rule 2(a)(i)]
19. A Secretary to the Government, though not required to, personally signed the appointment order of a Group C employee whose normal appointing authority is the head of office. Who can dismiss this employee?
(a) Any gazetted officer of the office
(b) The Secretary or an authority higher than the Secretary
(c) The head of office, as the authority named in the Schedule
(d) The head of office with the Secretary's oral approval
Ans. (b) The Secretary or an authority higher than the Secretary — Explanation: The authority which actually appointed him is counted under Rule 2(a) and the highest prevails; under Article 311(1) no authority below the Secretary may dismiss him. [Ref: Rule 2(a)(iii); Article 311(1)]
20. Delegation of the President's powers under Rule 8 has been made, for example, to which of the following?
(a) The Central Administrative Tribunal
(b) The Staff Selection Commission
(c) Administrators of certain Union Territories
(d) The Union Public Service Commission
Ans. (c) Administrators of certain Union Territories — Explanation: Government decisions under Rule 8 record delegation of appointment powers to Administrators of Union Territories such as Goa, Daman and Diu, and Dadra and Nagar Haveli; recruiting bodies and tribunals do not appoint. [Ref: Rule 8, Government of India decisions]
21. Does Article 311(1) protect a temporary Government servant against dismissal by an authority subordinate to his appointing authority?
(a) No; it protects only permanent Government servants
(b) Yes, but only after five years of service
(c) No; it protects only gazetted officers
(d) Yes; it applies to every holder of a civil post, permanent or temporary
Ans. (d) Yes; it applies to every holder of a civil post, permanent or temporary — Explanation: Article 311 draws no distinction between permanent and temporary holders of civil posts. [Ref: Article 311(1)]
22. What is meant by appointing authority being determined "for the time being" under Rule 2(a)?
(a) Only the authority competent at the time of first appointment is considered
(b) The appointing authority is fixed permanently on joining
(c) The appointing authority changes every time he is transferred
(d) The authority competent to appoint to his present Service, grade or post at the relevant time is considered
Ans. (d) The authority competent to appoint to his present Service, grade or post at the relevant time is considered — Explanation: Rule 2(a) refers to the Service, grade or post of which he is "for the time being" a member or holder, read with the authority that actually appointed him, the highest prevailing. [Ref: Rule 2(a)]
23. Consider the statements: (i) Rule 9(1) governs appointments to Group A Services. (ii) Appointments to Group A Services and posts are made by the President, subject to delegation. Which is/are correct?
(a) Only (i)
(b) Only (ii)
(c) Both (i) and (ii)
(d) Neither (i) nor (ii)
Ans. (b) Only (ii) — Explanation: Group A appointments are governed by Rule 8, which vests them in the President subject to delegation; Rule 9 deals with other Groups. [Ref: Rules 8 and 9]
24. Assertion (A): A Government servant appointed by a Chief Commissioner cannot be dismissed by a Commissioner, even if the Commissioner is now competent to make appointments to that post. Reason (R): Article 311(1) bars dismissal by an authority subordinate to that by which the person was appointed.
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
(c) A is true but R is false
(d) A is false but R is true
Ans. (a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A — Explanation: The actual appointing authority was the Chief Commissioner, so the Commissioner is subordinate to it, and Article 311(1) explains why he cannot dismiss. [Ref: Article 311(1); Rule 2(a)]
25. Assertion (A): Article 311(1) bars suspension of a Government servant by an authority subordinate to the appointing authority. Reason (R): Article 311(1) bars dismissal or removal by an authority subordinate to the appointing authority.
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
(c) A is true but R is false
(d) A is false but R is true
Ans. (d) A is false but R is true — Explanation: Article 311(1) covers only dismissal and removal; suspension is governed by Rule 10, which permits even the disciplinary authority to suspend. [Ref: Article 311(1); Rule 10(1)]
Want all 1,000 CCS (CCA) Rules questions in one PDF? The CCS (CCA) Rules ebook has all 40 sets with answers, explanations and quick-revision tables of time limits, penalties, suspension, appeals and case law. Launch offer: ₹99 MRP ₹200. Get the ebook
Next: Set 5. See all sets under the label CCS CCA Rules. For exam preparation, attempt the full set before checking answers and revise the topic of every question you miss.
These questions are prepared for practice from the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 as amended (including the 2014, 2017, 2022 and January 2026 amendments), DoPT and CVC instructions, and Supreme Court judgments. Check the latest DoPT notifications and orders before relying on any detail.