Skip to content
Join Telegram

RTI Act MCQ Set 10: Section 8(1)(a) to (e): Exemptions I (25 Questions with Answers)

RTI ActService Rules

This is Set 10 of 40 in the smartvidya question bank on the Right to Information Act, 2005 and RTI Rules, 2012, with the latest amendments. Part II: Right to information and obligations of public authorities. This set covers Sovereignty and security, court prohibitions, legislative privilege, commercial confidence and fiduciary relationship.

Try each question first, then tap Show answer to see the correct option, a short explanation and the section or rule reference. The questions are useful for departmental and promotion examinations, for PIOs and First Appellate Authorities, and for citizens who use the RTI Act.

Set 10: Section 8(1)(a) to (e): Exemptions I

1. Section 8(1) of the RTI Act begins with the words
(a) "With the consent of the Minister"
(b) "Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, there shall be no obligation to give any citizen"
(c) "Subject to the approval of the Commission"
(d) "In the interest of the public authority"
Ans. (b) "Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, there shall be no obligation to give any citizen" — Explanation: Section 8(1) lists categories of information that need not be disclosed. [Ref: Section 8(1)]

2. Information whose disclosure would prejudicially affect the sovereignty and integrity of India is exempt under
(a) Section 24
(b) Section 8(1)(g)
(c) Section 8(1)(a)
(d) Section 8(1)(b)
Ans. (c) Section 8(1)(a) — Explanation: Section 8(1)(a) covers sovereignty, integrity, security, strategic, scientific or economic interests and foreign relations. [Ref: Section 8(1)(a)]

3. Which of these is NOT among the interests protected by Section 8(1)(a)?
(a) Relation with a foreign State
(b) The reputation of a public servant
(c) Strategic, scientific or economic interests of the State
(d) The security of the State
Ans. (b) The reputation of a public servant — Explanation: Reputation is not a ground under Section 8(1)(a). [Ref: Section 8(1)(a)]

4. Information whose disclosure would lead to incitement of an offence is exempt under
(a) Section 8(1)(e)
(b) Section 8(1)(a)
(c) Section 8(1)(h)
(d) Section 8(1)(c)
Ans. (b) Section 8(1)(a) — Explanation: Incitement of an offence is part of Section 8(1)(a). [Ref: Section 8(1)(a)]

5. Information expressly forbidden to be published by any court of law or tribunal is exempt under
(a) Section 8(1)(h)
(b) Section 9
(c) Section 8(1)(b)
(d) Section 8(1)(c)
Ans. (c) Section 8(1)(b) — Explanation: Section 8(1)(b) also covers disclosure that may constitute contempt of court. [Ref: Section 8(1)(b)]

6. The mere fact that a matter is sub judice
(a) bars disclosure if the PIO is a party
(b) bars disclosure only in criminal cases
(c) always bars disclosure
(d) is not by itself a ground for refusal; the bar is only where a court has expressly forbidden publication or disclosure would be contempt
Ans. (d) is not by itself a ground for refusal; the bar is only where a court has expressly forbidden publication or disclosure would be contempt — Explanation: Section 8(1)(b) requires an express prohibition or a risk of contempt. [Ref: Section 8(1)(b)]

7. Information whose disclosure would cause a breach of privilege of Parliament or a State Legislature is exempt under
(a) Section 8(1)(b)
(b) Section 8(1)(c)
(c) Section 8(1)(i)
(d) Section 8(3)
Ans. (b) Section 8(1)(c) — Explanation: Section 8(1)(c) protects legislative privilege. [Ref: Section 8(1)(c)]

8. Information including commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property, which would harm the competitive position of a third party, is exempt under
(a) Section 8(1)(j)
(b) Section 8(1)(d), unless larger public interest warrants disclosure
(c) Section 8(1)(e), absolutely
(d) Section 9
Ans. (b) Section 8(1)(d), unless larger public interest warrants disclosure — Explanation: Section 8(1)(d) has a larger public interest override. [Ref: Section 8(1)(d)]

9. Under Section 8(1)(d), who must be satisfied that larger public interest warrants disclosure?
(a) The competent authority
(b) The third party
(c) The Minister
(d) The applicant
Ans. (a) The competent authority — Explanation: The competent authority must be satisfied about larger public interest. [Ref: Section 8(1)(d)]

10. Information available to a person in a fiduciary relationship is exempt under
(a) Section 8(1)(e), unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger public interest warrants disclosure
(b) Section 8(1)(a)
(c) Section 8(1)(f)
(d) Section 11 only
Ans. (a) Section 8(1)(e), unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger public interest warrants disclosure — Explanation: Section 8(1)(e) protects fiduciary relationships subject to public interest. [Ref: Section 8(1)(e)]

11. In CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011), the Supreme Court held that evaluated answer books
(a) are exempt under Section 8(1)(e)
(b) are not records
(c) can be seen only by the CIC
(d) are information, and examining bodies do not hold them in a fiduciary capacity towards examinees
Ans. (d) are information, and examining bodies do not hold them in a fiduciary capacity towards examinees — Explanation: Examinees are entitled to inspect their evaluated answer books, subject to protection of examiners' identities. [Ref: Section 8(1)(e); CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011)]

12. In RBI v. Jayantilal N. Mistry (2015), the Supreme Court held that RBI
(a) can deny all information on banks under Section 8(1)(e)
(b) is a private body
(c) is outside the RTI Act
(d) does not hold information about banks in a fiduciary relationship and must disclose inspection reports subject to exemptions
Ans. (d) does not hold information about banks in a fiduciary relationship and must disclose inspection reports subject to exemptions — Explanation: The Court rejected the fiduciary claim of RBI as a regulator. [Ref: Section 8(1)(e); Jayantilal Mistry (2015)]

13. The exemption for commercial confidence in Section 8(1)(d) protects mainly
(a) the convenience of the public authority
(b) Cabinet papers
(c) the competitive position of a third party
(d) the privacy of officers
Ans. (c) the competitive position of a third party — Explanation: The test is harm to the competitive position of a third party. [Ref: Section 8(1)(d)]

14. Information about a country's defence preparedness is ordinarily exempt under
(a) Section 8(1)(a), as relating to security of the State
(b) Section 9
(c) Section 8(1)(d)
(d) Section 8(1)(j)
Ans. (a) Section 8(1)(a), as relating to security of the State — Explanation: Security and strategic interests are covered by Section 8(1)(a). [Ref: Section 8(1)(a)]

15. Section 8(1)(a) to (j) exemptions are
(a) applicable only to private bodies
(b) available only to the CIC
(c) permissive grounds on which disclosure need not be made, to be applied with reasons
(d) mandatory bars that apply automatically to whole files
Ans. (c) permissive grounds on which disclosure need not be made, to be applied with reasons — Explanation: The PIO must apply the exemption to the specific information and give reasons under Section 7(8). [Ref: Sections 8(1) and 7(8)]

16. Which exemption has a built-in "larger public interest" override in the clause itself?
(a) Section 8(1)(b)
(b) Section 8(1)(c)
(c) Section 8(1)(a)
(d) Section 8(1)(e)
Ans. (d) Section 8(1)(e) — Explanation: Clauses 8(1)(d) and 8(1)(e) contain larger public interest language within them. [Ref: Section 8(1)(e)]

17. A bid evaluated and contract awarded: the rates of the successful bidder in a Government contract are generally
(a) exempt under Section 24
(b) always exempt under Section 8(1)(d)
(c) disclosable, as the contract is concluded and public interest in spending is high
(d) exempt under Section 8(1)(a)
Ans. (c) disclosable, as the contract is concluded and public interest in spending is high — Explanation: After award, contract value and rates are usually disclosed; specific trade secrets may still be protected. [Ref: Section 8(1)(d)]

18. Information covered by an injunction of a High Court prohibiting its publication falls under
(a) Section 8(1)(c)
(b) Section 8(1)(b)
(c) Section 8(1)(h)
(d) Section 8(3)
Ans. (b) Section 8(1)(b) — Explanation: Express prohibition by a court attracts Section 8(1)(b). [Ref: Section 8(1)(b)]

19. The term "economic interests of the State" appears in
(a) Section 8(1)(i)
(b) Section 8(1)(d)
(c) Section 8(1)(e)
(d) Section 8(1)(a)
Ans. (d) Section 8(1)(a) — Explanation: Section 8(1)(a) mentions strategic, scientific or economic interests. [Ref: Section 8(1)(a)]

20. Consider: (i) Section 8(1)(c) protects privileges of Parliament and State Legislatures. (ii) Section 8(1)(b) protects court prohibitions. Which is correct?
(a) Only (i)
(b) Only (ii)
(c) Both (i) and (ii)
(d) Neither (i) nor (ii)
Ans. (c) Both (i) and (ii) — Explanation: Both clauses protect these institutions. [Ref: Section 8(1)(b) and (c)]

21. An examining body refuses to show a candidate his own evaluated answer sheet, claiming fiduciary relationship. Applying the Supreme Court's view, the refusal is
(a) not justified
(b) justified under Section 8(1)(e)
(c) justified under Section 8(1)(a)
(d) justified under Section 9
Ans. (a) not justified — Explanation: CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay held answer books must be shown. [Ref: CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011)]

22. The fiduciary exemption under Section 8(1)(e) is based on a relationship of
(a) trust and confidence, where one holds information for the benefit of another
(b) buyer and seller
(c) court and litigant only
(d) employer and contractor only
Ans. (a) trust and confidence, where one holds information for the benefit of another — Explanation: Courts have explained fiduciary relationship as one of trust and confidence. [Ref: Section 8(1)(e)]

23. Intellectual property information is mentioned in
(a) Section 8(1)(d)
(b) Section 8(1)(e)
(c) Section 9
(d) Section 8(1)(f)
Ans. (a) Section 8(1)(d) — Explanation: Section 8(1)(d) mentions commercial confidence, trade secrets and intellectual property. [Ref: Section 8(1)(d)]

24. Which of these is exempt under Section 8(1)(a) as relating to a foreign State?
(a) Information received from a foreign State in confidence, which is under Section 8(1)(f)
(b) Information about foreign trips of officers
(c) Any information mentioning a foreign country
(d) Information whose disclosure would prejudicially affect relations with a foreign State
Ans. (d) Information whose disclosure would prejudicially affect relations with a foreign State — Explanation: Section 8(1)(a) protects relations; confidential information from foreign Governments is under Section 8(1)(f). [Ref: Section 8(1)(a)]

25. Assertion (A): Commercial secrets of a supplier may be withheld. Reason (R): Section 8(1)(d) protects them unless larger public interest warrants disclosure.
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
(c) A is true but R is false
(d) A is false but R is true
Ans. (a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A — Explanation: Section 8(1)(d) is the basis of the protection. [Ref: Section 8(1)(d)]

Want all 1,000 RTI questions in one PDF? The RTI Act and Rules ebook has all 40 sets with answers, explanations and quick-revision tables of time limits, fees, exemptions and case law. Launch offer: ₹99 MRP ₹200. Get the ebook

Next: Set 11. See all sets under the label RTI Act. For exam preparation, attempt the full set before checking answers and revise the topic of every question you miss.

These questions are prepared for practice from the Right to Information Act, 2005 as amended (including the 2019 amendment and the November 2025 change to Section 8(1)(j) made by the DPDP Act, 2023), the RTI Rules, 2012 and the 2019 Rules. Check the latest notifications and DoPT instructions before relying on any detail.